The basics
What is credit card surcharging?
Credit card surcharging is the practice of adding a small fee to a credit card transaction at the point of sale to offset the cost of processing that transaction. Instead of the business absorbing the entire processing fee, the surcharge passes some or all of that cost to the customer who chooses to pay by credit card.
The surcharge appears as a separate line item on the customer’s receipt, clearly labelled. The customer sees the purchase price, the surcharge amount, and the total.
Is surcharging the same as a convenience fee?
No. They are different in both structure and regulation.
Surcharging applies specifically to credit card transactions. It is a fee for using a credit card as the payment method. It cannot be applied to debit card transactions, even if the debit card is processed through a credit card network.
A convenience fee is charged for using an alternative payment channel, not a specific card type. For example, a government office might charge a convenience fee for paying a bill online instead of in person. Convenience fees are governed by different rules and are typically limited to specific industries and payment scenarios.
If you are a standard retail, restaurant, or service business, what you are looking at is surcharging, not convenience fees.
Is surcharging legal?
In the United States, surcharging is legal at the federal level following the 2013 settlement in the Merchants Payment Coalition lawsuit against Visa and Mastercard. However, a small number of states have laws that either prohibit or restrict surcharging. The legal landscape has evolved significantly, and several states that previously banned surcharging have had their bans struck down by courts as unconstitutional restrictions on free speech.
In Canada, surcharging became legal nationwide following a 2022 settlement between Visa, Mastercard, and the Merchant Acceptance Corporation. Canadian merchants have been permitted to surcharge since October 6, 2022, subject to specific rules and caps set by the card networks.
| Important legal note Surcharging laws change. Several US states are actively litigating surcharging restrictions. Always verify the current law in your specific state or province before implementing a surcharge program. Payzium can help you determine whether surcharging is permitted in your jurisdiction. |
Which US states currently restrict or prohibit surcharging?
As of early 2025, the states with active surcharging restrictions are Connecticut and Massachusetts. Several other states (including Colorado, Kansas, Maine, New York, Oklahoma, and Texas) previously had surcharging bans that have been struck down by courts, modified by legislation, or are under active legal challenge.
Puerto Rico also has restrictions on surcharging.
| Payzium tip Because the legal status shifts as court decisions are handed down and legislatures update their codes, we recommend confirming your state’s current status before launch. Payzium monitors surcharging legislation across all 50 states and can confirm your eligibility when you set up your account. |
What are the rules for surcharging in Canada?
Canadian surcharging rules are governed by the card network settlement and the applicable provincial regulations. The key requirements are:
- The surcharge cannot exceed the merchant’s actual cost of acceptance for credit card transactions.
- The surcharge is capped at a maximum of 2.4% of the transaction amount.
- Merchants must provide clear disclosure to customers at the store entrance, point of sale, and on the receipt.
- Merchants must notify their payment processor and the card networks at least 30 days before implementing a surcharge.
- The surcharge applies only to credit cards. It cannot be applied to debit transactions, including Visa Debit or Mastercard Debit.
- Quebec has specific consumer protection regulations that may affect surcharging implementation. Merchants in Quebec should review provincial rules carefully.
How surcharging works in practice
How much can I surcharge?
The card networks (Visa and Mastercard) set a cap on the maximum surcharge amount. In the United States, the cap is 3% of the transaction amount or the merchant’s actual cost of acceptance, whichever is lower. In Canada, the cap is 2.4% or the merchant’s actual cost of acceptance, whichever is lower.
In practice, most merchants surcharge between 2% and 3% in the US and between 1.5% and 2.4% in Canada. The exact amount should reflect your actual processing costs. If your effective rate is 2.5%, your surcharge should be 2.5% or less.
| Do not surcharge above your cost Setting a surcharge higher than your actual cost of acceptance violates the card network rules and could result in fines or termination of your surcharging privileges. It also alienates customers. The surcharge should recover your processing cost, not generate additional profit. |
Can I surcharge debit card transactions?
No. This is the single most important rule in surcharging and the one most likely to cause problems if violated. Surcharges can only be applied to credit card transactions. They cannot be applied to:
- Debit card transactions (including PIN debit)
- Prepaid card transactions
- Visa Debit or Mastercard Debit transactions (in Canada, these look like credit cards but are linked to a chequing account)
- EBT (Electronic Benefits Transfer) cards
Your terminal or point-of-sale system must be able to distinguish between credit and debit transactions and automatically exclude debit from the surcharge. If your system cannot do this, you cannot legally implement a surcharge program.
| Payzium approach Every Payzium surcharge setup includes terminal configuration that automatically identifies the card type before applying any surcharge. If a customer inserts a debit card, the surcharge is not applied. This is handled at the terminal level so you and your staff do not have to make the determination manually. |
What does the customer see?
Transparency is mandatory. The customer must be informed about the surcharge at multiple points:
At the entrance: A clearly visible sign at the door or entrance to your business stating that a surcharge is applied to credit card transactions. The sign must display the surcharge percentage.
At the point of sale: A sign or decal at the register, payment terminal, or checkout counter. For e-commerce, the surcharge must be disclosed on the checkout page before the customer completes the transaction.
On the receipt: The surcharge must appear as a separate line item on the receipt. The customer sees the subtotal, the surcharge amount, and the total. The surcharge cannot be buried in the purchase price.
| Example receipt Subtotal: $85.00 Credit card surcharge (2.5%): $2.13 Total: $87.13 |
The surcharge must also be transmitted to the card network as a separate data element in the transaction, not lumped into the sale amount. Your processor handles this on the back end.
Do I need to notify anyone before I start surcharging?
Yes. Before implementing a surcharge program, you are required to:
- Notify Visa and Mastercard at least 30 days before you begin surcharging. Your processor can handle this notification on your behalf.
- Notify your payment processor so they can configure your account and terminal to process surcharges correctly.
- Post the required signage at your business location.
Failure to provide proper notification can result in fines from the card networks or loss of your ability to surcharge.
Customer impact and best practices
Will surcharging drive customers away?
This is the question every business owner asks, and the honest answer is: it depends on how you handle it.
Surcharging has become increasingly common and increasingly accepted. Gas stations have offered cash discounts (the functional equivalent of a surcharge) for decades. Customers are familiar with the concept. Government offices, utilities, and medical practices surcharge routinely. The practice is normalizing.
That said, execution matters enormously. Businesses that surprise customers with a surcharge at checkout get complaints. Businesses that disclose it upfront, explain it clearly, and offer a debit or cash alternative experience minimal pushback.
The data supports this. Most industry surveys indicate that 85% to 90% of customers will still pay with their credit card even when a surcharge is disclosed, because the convenience of credit outweighs the small additional cost. Of the remaining 10% to 15%, most simply switch to debit rather than leaving.
What is the best way to communicate the surcharge to customers?
Treat it as a straightforward business practice, not something to hide or apologize for. The most effective approach has four elements:
Clear signage: A professional sign at the entrance and at the register. Not a handwritten note. A clean, branded sign that states the surcharge percentage and that debit, cash, and other non-credit methods are not surcharged. Payzium provides compliant signage as part of every surcharge setup.
Staff training: Your team should be able to explain the surcharge in one sentence if a customer asks: “We apply a small surcharge on credit card transactions to cover processing costs. There is no surcharge on debit or cash.” That is it. No lengthy justification needed.
Offer alternatives: Always frame it as a choice. The customer can pay by credit card and accept the surcharge, or they can pay by debit, cash, or another method with no additional cost. Giving people a choice defuses most objections.
Keep the percentage reasonable: A 2% surcharge on a $50 purchase is $1.00. Most customers will not even notice. A 3% surcharge on a $500 purchase is $15.00. That is more visible and more likely to draw questions. If your average ticket is high, consider whether a slightly lower surcharge percentage might be strategically smarter even if it does not fully recover your costs.
Can I offer a cash discount instead of a surcharge?
Yes, and some merchants prefer this approach because it is framed positively. Instead of adding a fee for credit card use, you offer a discount for paying with cash or debit. The economic effect is identical, but the customer perception can be different.
However, there are important distinctions:
- A cash discount must be applied as a discount from a clearly posted credit card price. You cannot set a base price and then add a surcharge while calling it a “cash discount program.” Some third-party programs marketed as “cash discount” programs are actually surcharge programs in disguise and may violate card network rules.
- Disclosure requirements still apply. The posted price must be the credit card price, and the discount must be clearly displayed.
- Cash discounts are legal in all 50 states and all Canadian provinces with fewer restrictions than surcharging.
| Beware of non-compliant programs Several companies market “zero-cost processing” or “cash discount” programs that are actually non-compliant surcharge programs. They set the base price as the cash price, add a fee at the terminal, and label it something other than a surcharge. Visa and Mastercard have increased enforcement against these programs. If a provider tells you their program “is not surcharging” but it adds a fee to credit card transactions, get that claim in writing and verify it independently. |
The financial impact
How much will surcharging actually save me?
The savings depend on your processing volume, your effective rate, and the percentage of customers who pay by credit card. Here are three scenarios:
| Small retailer | Mid-size restaurant | Professional services | |
| Monthly volume | $15,000 | $45,000 | $80,000 |
| % credit card | 60% | 70% | 85% |
| Credit volume | $9,000 | $31,500 | $68,000 |
| Effective rate | 2.8% | 2.6% | 2.5% |
| Current credit fees | $252/mo | $819/mo | $1,700/mo |
| Surcharge recovery (est. 90%) | $227/mo | $737/mo | $1,530/mo |
| Annual savings | $2,724 | $8,844 | $18,360 |
The 90% recovery estimate accounts for the fact that some customers will switch to debit (no surcharge) and the surcharge percentage may be slightly below your full effective rate. Even conservatively, surcharging recovers the vast majority of your credit card processing costs.
Do I still pay processing fees if I surcharge?
Yes. Surcharging does not eliminate your processing fees. Your processor still charges interchange, assessments, and their markup on every transaction. What changes is who bears the cost. Instead of your business absorbing the credit card processing fee, the surcharge shifts that cost to the customer who chose to use a credit card.
Your debit card transactions are unaffected. You continue to pay processing fees on those at the standard rate (which is significantly lower than credit card rates). This is one of the reasons surcharging works well: you recover the expensive credit card fees while continuing to pay the much cheaper debit card fees yourself.
What if only some of my transactions are credit cards?
That is actually ideal. The lower your credit card percentage, the less you are currently spending on processing fees, and the surcharge still recovers most of what you do spend. Even if only 40% of your transactions are credit card, surcharging that 40% can recover thousands per year.
The business case is strongest for merchants with a high credit card percentage (60%+), because the absolute dollar amount of recoverable fees is larger. But there is no minimum threshold. If you process credit cards, surcharging can benefit you.
Setting up a surcharge program
What do I need to get started?
A compliant surcharge program requires four things:
- A payment terminal or POS system that can identify card type (credit vs. debit) and automatically apply or exclude the surcharge. Not all terminals support this. Your processor will confirm compatibility or provide compliant equipment.
- Card network notification submitted at least 30 days before launch. Your processor handles this.
- Compliant signage at your entrance and point of sale displaying the surcharge percentage and the fact that debit and cash are exempt.
- Staff who understand the program and can explain it to customers in a clear, professional sentence.
Can I surcharge on online transactions?
Yes, surcharging applies to both card-present (in-store) and card-not-present (online, phone order) transactions. For e-commerce, the surcharge must be disclosed on the checkout page before the customer submits payment. The surcharge amount must be clearly visible as a separate line item, not hidden in the total.
Your payment gateway must support surcharging and must be configured to apply it only to credit cards. Most modern gateways support this, but you should confirm with your processor before launch.
How long does it take to set up?
The card network notification requires 30 days of lead time. During that 30-day window, your processor configures your terminal or gateway, orders and ships signage, and prepares your account. When the notification period expires, you flip the switch and start surcharging.
Total timeline from decision to go-live: approximately 4 to 5 weeks.
What if I want to stop surcharging later?
You can stop at any time. There is no commitment to continue surcharging once you start. Simply remove the signage, have your processor disable the surcharge on your terminal, and notify the card networks. There is no fee or penalty for stopping.
Some merchants implement surcharging seasonally or adjust their surcharge percentage periodically based on their processing costs. This is permitted as long as you maintain compliant disclosure and do not exceed the caps.
Surcharging compliance checklist
Use this checklist to ensure your surcharge program meets all card network and legal requirements.
| Requirement | Confirmed? |
| Surcharging is legal in your state or province | |
| Surcharge does not exceed your actual cost of acceptance | |
| Surcharge does not exceed the network cap (3% US / 2.4% Canada) | |
| Surcharge applies only to credit cards (not debit, prepaid, or EBT) | |
| Visa and Mastercard notified at least 30 days before launch | |
| Payment processor notified and account configured | |
| Terminal or POS system automatically identifies credit vs. debit | |
| Signage posted at store entrance with surcharge percentage | |
| Signage posted at point of sale / checkout | |
| Surcharge appears as separate line item on customer receipt | |
| Surcharge transmitted as separate data element in transaction | |
| Staff trained to explain the surcharge clearly | |
| E-commerce checkout discloses surcharge before payment (if applicable) | |
| Surcharge amount reviewed quarterly against actual processing costs |
Ready to explore surcharging?
If you are considering a surcharge program, Payzium can walk you through the process from start to finish. We will confirm whether surcharging is legal in your jurisdiction, calculate your potential savings based on your actual transaction data, handle the card network notification, configure your terminal, provide compliant signage, and train your staff.
If surcharging is not the right fit for your business, we will tell you. Some businesses benefit more from optimized interchange-plus pricing alone. We will help you figure out which approach delivers the best result.
| Find out if surcharging is right for your business Email sales@payzium.com with your monthly volume and we will run the numbers or call us at 888-546-4919 |
Transparent, reliable payment processing with clear pricing, consistent deposits, and responsive support.